Bone broth, or collagen? THAT is the query. Bone broth has collagen. So, collagen has…bone broth? No, however, each of those two merchandise have exploded on the wellness scene just lately, and, most of the time, are used interchangeably.
However is taking a collagen complement the identical factor as consuming bone broth?
What’s the distinction between bone broth and collagen?
Do bone broth and collagen provide the identical advantages?
Which one is healthier?
Or do you have to take each?
Right here, we’ll reply all these questions and break down the distinction between bone broth and collagen peptides, powders, and dietary supplements.
WHAT IS COLLAGEN?
Collagen is essentially the most ample protein within the physique. It’s made up of a mix of amino acids, primarily, glycine, proline, hydroxyproline, and arginine. It’s this particular mixture of those 4 amino acids that makes collagen so particular.
You can not discover this mix of amino acids, on this focus, in ANY different protein supply.
These 4 key amino acids assist give construction to our hair, pores and skin, nails, bones, ligaments, tendons and intestine lining. They make our muscle tissues develop, our our bodies versatile, our pores and skin tight and plump, and our hair shiny.
Collagen makes as much as 70% of the protein inside our pores and skin, serving to it keep toned and supple.
Sounds lots like The Fountain of Youth, proper? That’s as a result of after we’re younger and spry collagen manufacturing is at its peak. Sadly, as we become older – after the age of 30 to be precise – our physique’s collagen manufacturing begins to fall.
You could have already observed your pores and skin trying drier? Just a few extra strains and wrinkles? Joints popping and clicking WAY greater than they used to if you’re twerking on the dance ground???
Don’t despair!
Analysis reveals that by consuming collagen protein, you’ll be able to assist make up for what your physique lacks.
*Resume Pleased Dance.*
There are two methods that you may complement with collagen: collagen “peptides,” which are available a large number of kinds, mostly capsules and powders, or, the whole-food type of collagen: bone broth.
WHAT ARE “HYDROLYZED” OR POWDERED COLLAGEN PEPTIDES?
Let’s begin with the collagen dietary supplements. You’ve most likely heard the time period collagen “peptides” or, “hydrolyzed” collagen, these are the identical factor – a powdered type of collagen that has been extracted from bovine hides (cow pores and skin) – not bones.
The animal hides are washed and soaked in an alkaline or acid answer – usually a lime slurry pit – to loosen the collagen bonds; the hides are then boiled to extract the collagen. The extracted collagen is evaporated, concentrated, desiccated in drum driers, after which pulverized, which ends up in the powder type of collagen. (NOTE: Info on the substances and processing of any collagen powder or complement must be available on the producer’s web site.)
HOW IS BONE BROTH DIFFERENT FROM COLLAGEN PEPTIDES?
There are a number of ways in which bone broth differs from collagen peptides…
Solely Bones
For starters, when ready accurately (learn extra about how you can inform in case your bone broth is legit HERE), bone broth is created from animal bones. And JUST bones (plus some hen toes, joint tissue, and cartilage when you’re doin’ it proper). NO pores and skin or meat. Collagen peptides, then again, are created from animal hides, or, skins, which ends up in a unique collagen profile in addition to general nutrient content material.
Extra Vitamins
Collagen peptides are a quite simple complement containing one factor: collagen. Bone broth incorporates a number of vitamins, together with naturally-occurring chondroitin sulfate, which is present in bones and cartilage, hyaluronic acid, discovered within the synovial fluid of joints, and practically 20 different types of amino acids, plus minerals comparable to calcium, magnesium, potassium, and phosphorus. Lastly, bone broth additionally incorporates alkylglycerols- lipids which were proven to have highly effective immune-supporting properties.
Diploma of Processing
As outlined above, making powdered collagen peptides includes a number of levels of processing. Historically-made bone broth solely undergoes one course of: slow-simmering bones in water for 18-48 hours.
At Bonafide Provisions, we slow-simmer (by no means boil) our bone broth at a mild, low warmth for at least 18 hours with a purpose to extract all of the collagen. Our bone broth is then cooled and frozen-fresh to protect nutrient content material at its peak. CLICK HERE TO LEARN MORE ABOUT OUR TRADITIONAL PREPARATION PROCESS.
Bioavailable Collagen
At Bonafide Provisions, we imagine that the human physique developed consuming meals and, in consequence, is extra capable of acknowledge, digest, and use vitamins contained in meals.
(NOTE: whereas we’re NOT scientists or medical doctors, we’re consultants in widespread sense…)
Our founder, Sharon Brown, is an authorized Scientific Nutritionist and her expertise working with hundreds of vitamin shoppers throughout the nation taught her that, many occasions, the physique doesn’t acknowledge or use manufactured vitamins the identical approach it does vitamins from whole-food sources.
That is to not say the physique can’t use vitamins from dietary supplements – we take just a few dietary supplements ourselves – however it’s our expertise and opinion that, when given the selection, the physique prefers whole-food sources of vitamins.
Bone broth is without doubt one of the most bioavailable sources of collagen as a result of it is available in a whole-food kind.
“I think collagen is interesting and there is some data out there suggesting benefit, but I prefer for my patients to eat food,” says Valori Treloar, Massachusetts dermatologist & nutritionist.
WHICH ONE IS BETTER?
Analysis reveals that utilizing easy collagen peptides does work for reaching the focused outcomes of collagen, comparable to lowering wrinkles and strengthening and thickening your hair, pores and skin, and nails.
Bone broth, then again, is extra of an all-inclusive well being complement offering a large number of vitamins that help intestine well being, mind well being, joint & bone well being, and immunity, along with strengthening your hair, pores and skin and nails.
You additionally don’t should determine between one or the opposite as they’ve totally different makes use of.
Collagen peptides or powdered gelatin can be utilized in baking so as to add a chewy, gummy texture to cookies and make home made gummy collagen candies.
Bone broth can be utilized to make, nicely, absolutely anything. Severely.
Bone broth is NOT only for soup!
You should use bone broth instead of liquid in nearly any recipe.
We put bone broth in our smoothies (sure, SMOOTHIES), in our waffles, mashed potatoes, even our espresso; we use it to make our rice and quinoa, braise meats, sauté our greens, the record goes on and on!
So there you may have it, mates. Whereas bone broth and collagen should not the identical issues and don’t ship the identical advantages, each can have a spot in your kitchen, relying on what you are after.
Like this weblog? Know somebody who’s collagen-obsessed? Share this with them!