Questioning which might win in a battle: protein bars vs protein shakes? Let’s examine.
Pop quiz. You’re in a rush, and also you don’t have time to arrange a full meal. You assume, “I just need a quick hit of protein. That’ll do the trick.” However what do you go for? Do you have to attain for the protein bar, or whip up a fast protein shake? If you face them off collectively, protein bars vs protein shakes, which is best?
Our concepts of “eating healthy” are rooted in common perceptions. It’s why many individuals instantly equate “salad” with “healthy,” despite the fact that a salad can simply grow to be a weight loss plan killer with just a few toppings and an excessive amount of dressing. Equally, unwrapping a packaged protein bar might really feel much less “healthy” in comparison with tossing recent fruits and greens right into a blender. But it surely’s fairly simple to make an unhealthy shake, regardless of the recent produce, similar to it’s simple to seek out wholesome and not-so-healthy protein bars.
So, let’s examine the advantages and downsides of every to seek out which is best: protein bars vs. shakes.
The Benefits and Disadvantages of Protein Bars vs Shakes
Earlier than we dive in, there’s an essential piece to recollect—your definition of “better” can differ from the following individual’s. All of us have totally different wants and ranging life. Accordingly, it’s a must to discover the correct match for you. Like most dietary selections, there’s hardly ever a black and white reply, as a result of no dietary determination is made in a vacuum. That’s why we’ll give attention to laying out the benefits and downsides so you may determine for your self.
The Advantages of Protein Bars
There are an a variety of benefits to protein bars. Particularly, they’re tremendous handy. You’ll be able to squirrel some away in your cabinet, backpack, or automotive trunk so you’ve got them prepared everytime you want that additional increase. They’re prepared on the spot, and make for a number of the greatest mountaineering snacks — no must refrigerate, warmth, fuss or fidget. As well as, listed below are just a few extra advantages of protein bars:
Macronutrient Stability: Protein bars range from producer, however on the whole, they have a tendency to supply a greater stability of macronutrients than shakes. Once more, it is determined by the shake your utilizing or what you’re including to it. However in case you’re utilizing a protein powder in your shake, you’ll get a dose of protein, however fewer fats and carbs on common than you’ll from a protein bar. As an example, the Exo Peanut Butter and Jelly Protein Bar gives a combo of 10 g protein, 15 g fats, and 27 g of carbohydrate.
Satiety: Research have indicated that chewing strong meals is extra satiating than getting your energy in liquid kind. That’s one of many causes carbohydrate wealthy drinks are so dangerous — they supply a load of energy, however they’re not very satiating. So, feeling unhappy, you attain for extra. One of many causes bars are additionally satiating, is that they have a tendency to have extra fiber. Bars with 3 grams of fiber or extra per serving will provide help to to really feel extra full. Exo protein bars vary from 4 – 16 grams of fiber.
The Disadvantages of Protein Bars
Not all protein bars are created equal. Meaning it’s a must to take a look at the elements to be sure you’re making a sensible choice. Listed here are just a few of the frequent disadvantages of protein bars.
Sugar: This can be a threat you run into with any processed, packaged meals. However, protein bars might be main offenders, generally resembling one thing nearer to a sweet bar than a wholesome snack if you focus in on the elements. If you happen to see sugar, excessive fructose corn syrup, or sucrose on the high of the elements, search for a greater bar. Ideally, a majority of the sugar in your bar ought to come from pure elements, like fruit. A lot of the sugar in Exo bars originates from dried fruit, fruit juice, or puree.
Funky Fillers: You’ll be able to run into this drawback with protein shakes as nicely. Both approach, your search ought to start by scanning the ingredient checklist on the label. In a very good protein bar, you must solely see elements you could acknowledge and may pronounce. As an example, in case you scan the ingredient checklist on an Exo bar you’ll acknowledge a variety of seeds, nuts, fruits, and different pure elements… like crickets!
The Advantages of Protein Shakes
Like protein bars, protein shakes are usually pretty handy for getting protein into your system. And in some methods, they will truly be more practical at rapidly making that protein out there to your physique.
Protein Supply: For support in muscle restore and restoration, it’s essential to eat sufficient protein in your weight loss plan. It’s additionally been really useful to eat 0.14-0.23 grams of protein per pound of physique weight after a exercise to assist guarantee you’ve got the suitable constructing blocks out there for repairing muscle tissue. Research have additionally proven that amino acids (protein constructing blocks) are extra rapidly transported to the bloodstream when consumed in liquid kind. Meaning they’ll be extra rapidly out there to assist rebuild your muscle tissue.
Straightforward to Make at Residence: Certain, you might make protein bars at residence too. However they are usually tougher than making a shake. With a shake you simply have to collect some fruit, veggies, peanut butter, and possibly some protein powder, and toss them in your blender with some liquid of your alternative, hit ‘blend’, and there you’ve got it — pour and luxuriate in.
The Disadvantages of Protein Shakes – “protein bars vs shakes”
Protein shakes could also be simple to make at residence, however they’re not fairly as handy as protein bars are for taking over the go. You’ll be able to’t (or shouldn’t) actually retailer a protein shake unrefrigerated in your workplace desk drawer, or in your gymnasium bag. That’s one drawback. Listed here are two extra.
Starvation pangs: Since protein shakes are inclined to have much less macronutrient stability, and fewer fiber, they might go away you much less satiated. Proper after you eat one, you’re prone to really feel full, due to all of the liquid. But when it doesn’t have rather more than some protein powder, you would possibly end up hungry shortly thereafter.
Sugar: Yup, that’s proper. Identical to protein bars, protein shakes might be loaded with sugar. Quite a lot of protein powders can have pure sweeteners like stevia, however in case you’re not cautious you might find yourself with a carb bomb.
Are Protein Shakes or Protein Bars Higher?
As we’ve seen, protein bars and shakes each have benefits and downsides. Generally they’re even the identical. So, can we even identify a transparent minimize winner? Not so simply.
Protein Bars vs Shakes: Can They Coexist?
Every is suitable for various eventualities relying on private desire. If you happen to’re searching for a snack you could stash with you all through your day, a well-crafted protein bar generally is a handy and wholesome choice. So if you end up busy all through the day, and wish one thing handy, protein bars are in all probability higher.
However, in case you’re searching for one thing you could simply make your self at residence, and enhance the pace of protein supply after a exercise, you would possibly choose a protein shake.
Fairly than wholeheartedly committing to 1 or the opposite, you’re greatest off selecting a bar or shake primarily based on the particular state of affairs. Meaning they will cohabitate in your weight loss plan, so that you get one of the best of each worlds.
So long as you’re selecting merchandise with high-quality elements, each of them will work high quality.
What to Search for in Protein Bars and Protein Shakes
Do not forget that one of the best place to get protein is from complete meals sources. So, if you’re getting your protein from a processed meals, it ought to carefully resemble that of a complete meals when it comes to its composition.
Look at the Ingredient Checklist: You can begin out by scanning the ingredient checklist of the product. Search for gadgets that you simply acknowledge. If you happen to’re taking a look at a bar, you must see complete meals in that checklist, like fruits and nuts. Sugar shouldn’t be the primary ingredient in protein bars or protein shakes. If that’s the case, put it again and take a look at once more.
Protein Content material: The place does the bar or shake get its protein from? Ideally, it ought to come from complete meals elements like nuts, seeds, and eggs. Or, high-quality isolates and concentrates might be good choices as nicely. A few of the best-studied sources embrace whey, pea, and egg protein. For a protein bar, it ought to present between 10-20 g of protein per serving.
Sweeteners: Ensure you know the place the candy taste is coming from in your bar or shake. Attempt to keep away from bars and shakes with extra sugar, or that include issues like excessive fructose corn syrup. If sugar is the sweetener, strive to decide on merchandise which have elements with naturally occurring sugar. As an example, dried fruit is commonly included in protein bars which add each sugar and fiber. In case your bar or shake has a sugar different, grow to be accustomed to these totally different options. Sugar alcohols like maltitol, and xylitol typically trigger abdomen discomfort and diarrhea.
Energy: It’s essential to be aware of the energy in your protein bars or shakes, particularly since they will range fairly a bit. If it’s offering lower than 200-250 energy, you might take into account it to be extra of a snack. But when it’s going past that 250 energy, it’s beginning to extra resemble the calorie load of a meal. Simply concentrate on how your bar or shake is becoming in your day and luxuriate in!
Store Exo protein merchandise right here and take a look at our Instagram for extra concepts on learn how to incorporate protein into your day!
“protein bars vs shakes”